Categories: Musings

The 6-Degrees of Manga Adaptation Leads

If Kevin Bacon is the center of the Hollywood universe, I’ve yet to find his equivalent in the Asian entertainment world. Since we’ve been on such a Playful Kiss high lately, let’s spend a few minutes with the two young men who have breathed life into the character of Irie Naoki, Joe Cheng and Kim Hyun Joong, and then follow me for more curious case of the guys who played famous manga leads meeting in real life. 

Lots of you probably have seen the picture above, which was taken back in 2009 when Ariel Lin and Joe were giving actor awards by Yahoo Asia, and SS501 and Kim Hyun Joong won group and individual awards, respectively. This was way before Kim Hyun Joong was slated to play the same character made famous by Joe, but now this picture looks so prescient. I’ve noted that Kim Hyun Joong is quite tall in PK and towers over his leading actress Jung So Min, but I never really understood exactly how tall Joe was until I saw them side-by-side.

As a bonus, let’s make this six-degrees of separation even cooler. Joe was actually the MC at Lee Min Ho‘s Taiwan fanmeeting, and above are some pictures from that event.

Again, Lee Min Ho is one of the tallest actors in Korea, and Joe still has an inch or two on him. In addition, I’ve snuck in a picture of Lee Min Ho and Kim Hyun Joong doing an ad campaign for god-knows-what. Finally, recently Oguri Shun met up with Kim Hyun Joong in Korea. This ties together our actors from the most famous manga-to-drama adapation genre, each of whom have or will have played two famous manga leading men.

Lee Min Ho was or will be the Korean versions of Domyoji Tsukasa in Hana Yori Dango and Saeba Ryo in City Hunter. Kim Hyun Joong played the Korean versions of Hanazawa Rui in Hana Yori Dango and Irie Naoki in Itazura na Kiss. Joe Cheng played Taiwan versions of Irie Naoki in Itazura na Kiss and Hanatashiki Aoi (Chinese character name Han Kui) in Bara no Tame ni (drama title The Rose). Lastly, Oguri Shun played J-versions of Hanazawa Rui in Hana Yori Dango and Izumi Sano in Hanazakari no Kimitachi e.

So all  four of these guys have really made a mark in the manga-to-drama adaptation world in their respective countries. (I was going to throw in some Wu Zun goodness, who is now about to tackle his third manga character in the Zettai Kareshi re-make (after doing TW-HanaKimi and Tokyo Juliet), but that’ll have to wait). If Korea ever dared to remake Hanazakari no Kimitachi e, maybe someone else ought to join this distinguished group. Maybe my Moony?


ockoala

View Comments

  • Interesting article, really. I love it when my fandoms collide! :D
    And yeah, I've never noticed how tall Joe is. XD

  • Chingoo,you never cease to amaze me with your vast knowledge...please remind me NOT to play Jeopardy &/or Trivial Pursuits with ya...kisses

  • as much as i love hanakimi (the manga exclusively... the japanese version was super fun but wacky... shunnie was dashing though and that boosted toma's career so i guess i should be grateful for that but i didn't LOVE it... the tw version.. lots of eye candy but um.. wu zun speaks for himself.. as for ella. love HER, dislike her acting)
    and honestly, although i enjoyed all the cross-dressing dramas airing right now and previously, i think i need a break from them... but yoonie as sano would be really good... i want to see THAT. i wonder who would fit nakatsu's role...

    and i had the exact same remark about their heights when i saw that pic.. haha...
    pretty boy meets pretty boy meets other pretty who meets pretty boy...
    so many pretty boys...

    • oh... and wanted to add something about wu zun.. remember, he was in tokyo juliet as well... it's been a while ive read that manga but i remember his name is akira or something... i remember it because of NwP

      • aishh... at first i thought it was my mistake.. that i was pressing enter but everytime this is the second time the comment is submitted without me wanti

      • wanting it to... am i the only one having this problem??? TT sorry i didnt want to spam.. just wanted to say that i didn't like the first 2 adaptations of wu zun much so i w

      • as wondering how the 3rd would fare... TT. what's happening??? ockoala. feel free to delete my comments.. why do i have this problem

      • ok... i'm trying again to see if this works... it looks like it's working. YES! it's working. phew. I really thought my computer went beser

    • v

      I'm sorry, but your computer glitch problem causing you to keep posting before you were done writing, yeah, that was hella hilarious. Hope it's fixed, but I had a good laugh at your computer's expense this morning. I think it woke up on the wrong side of the bed.

      • i finally found out what the computer leak was about...
        my "enter" key was partially stuck... it got me worked up the whole morning (TT) but glad you got a laugh out of it.. XD

      • lol.. my roommate just told me the key is not called enter.. hehe.. i'm computer blind. it's called the left-click button. -_-"

  • hahhaha nice links :) KHJ looked so small next to Joe Cheng

    speaking of Wu Zhun... now his acting is one of the most awkward thing i've ever seen hahahaha! But I haven't seen anything from him lately, maybe he improved like KHJ did

    • My thought was more like: THAT is Oguri Shun?!?

      I needed to verify his identity multiple times. That man is not aging....in the right way.

  • It almost looks like Hyun Joong is standing in a hole in that picture. I know he is taller than Young Saeng and Hyung Joon and only an inch or two shorter than Jung min and Kyu Jong but he looks like he is the shortest in that picture.

    It really is a small world with how all of them are connected in one way or another. Very interesting how things come full circle sometimes.

  • Am I the only one who's still waiting the kdrama version of Zettai Kareshi?!?

    Joe's outfit at LMH's fanmeeting? *scratches head* And speaking of LMH, I don't know why, but even though I know he's tall, whenever I see him on screen, I keep thinking he's not.

    • Nope, not just you. The problem with LMH is that he doesn't fill up the screen like other guys who are equally as tall: Jung Woo Sung, Cha Seung Won, Lee Chun Hee, et. al.

      LMH has also lost a lot of weight, in PT he looked like a wind would blow him away, and when he turned sidedays sometimes I couldn't see him anymore.

      Hence, he doesn't project his real height as well as the other gigantors in the industry.

      • isnt being skinnier should project him taller? eg BiDam and his longggggg suave body.

        I think it's a case of proportions, LMH doesnt have a cd size head, same w/ Joe Cheng, so they do not appear as tall.

      • Okay, twinnie mookie is right again. LMH and Joe both had rather large leads. Joe is not as skinny as LHM so it doesn't seem as disproportionate. Either way, these guys can use a sandwich.

      • LMH is as hot as JWS, CSW and so on? WHAT?!? See? See? It's happening again. It's like my brain refuses to believe the evidence.

        LOL yes, he really looked like the wind could blow him away in PT.

        LOL you guys crack me up. I would have said that LMH's problem is his new unfortunate clothing style, with the short pants, same kind of pants that the oh so hot KNG was unlucky enough to wear on Bad Guy and btw, KNG looked shorter with those things on, too, imho...

  • great connection ockoala!

    joe cheng is really tall, thats why in ISWAK ariel lin looks like a grade schooler against the towering height of joe cheng.

    who would have thought that kim hyun joong and joe cheng who just met in 2009 would be giving life to the same character, Irie naoki.
    good thing both of them have different approach in playing the part.
    and both of them did well in their own way.

Recent Posts

Both IU and Byun Woo Seok’s Agencies Deny Rumors of Dropping Out of Upcoming Romance K-drama 21st Century Prince’s Wife

Oh this is juicy gossip, if it's out in the open there clearly is things…

15 hours ago

TW-actress Ariel Lin Announced Second Pregnancy Dispelling Recent Year Rumors of Marital Issues

I feel like almost every single celebrity marriage comes with gossip and rumors of problems…

1 day ago

Posters and Preview for SBS Sageuk The Haunted Palace with Yook Sung Jae, Bona, and Kim Ji Hoon Premiering April 2025

There is an upcoming sageuk coming in April that I'm planning to watch but not…

2 days ago

Park Sung Hoon Cast as the Male Lead in Romance K-drama Efficient Dating of Single Men and Women Opposite Han Ji Min

The great reception for Han Ji Min in her last romance K-drama makes sense that…

2 days ago