Jang Hee Jin Gets Praise and Seo Hyo Rim Gets Criticism for Different Levels of Sageuk Acting in MBC Drama The Red Sleeve Cuff

View Comments

• Seo Hyo Rim really getting on my nerves... her facial expression gives me I'm the villain vibes lol...

  but as always the woman is not getting as much praise compare to woman. Might be it's because she is a veteran acctress. Lee Se Young is doing an awsome job in it and her story is what makes me stay.

  • Yes, her eyes are bulging when she gets angry,I’m wondering if she has hyperthyroidism.. i think on sageuk dramas the royal villainess should be cool and collective and not crass,considering their status,they are more effective this way..

  • Yes, her eyes are bulging when she gets angry,I’m wondering if she has hyperthyroidism..

• Jang Heejin has been perfect in this role. I mean she gets her pockets of scenes and just run it with nuanced elegance.
  I especially love her scene with LSY.

  There is also Kang Malgeum, who plays CP's mom, who has been a scene stealer for me.

  • Agree the CP's mother is really good as well. The roles of women feel so much stronger and three dimensional here compared to most sageuks. Maybe because the writer and the director are both women.

• Playing the villain is harder.

  But honestly, I was kinda disapointed by both characters in the scene of the silk ceremony. I was expecting more and she just said she was wrong and it's all...

• Jung Hee Jin has more experience in Sageuks too. Not a fair criticism. She has done many Sageuks so its only natural that she is good. I'd say she is more charismatic than Lee Se Young here.

• i mean , Jung Hee Jin has been doing dramas sine forever so its natural she is amazing , she stands out even more than the female lead

  • why? just because she is charismatic? charisma # acting skills. she is good. but Le Se Young is better.

• Seo Hye Rim isn't getting as much criticism per se more like knetz are divided over if her acting suits the character or not. Some think she has poor diction and others think it suits the role. I can understand why Jang Hee Jin is getting heaps of praise though because she is killing it. In comparison Lee Se Young isn't impressive she is delivering her usual thing but it isn't next level wowza acting that Junho and the other casts are delivering.

  • Seo Hyeo Rim facial expression is spot on and she is actually good conveying emotion and spoiled brat aura. it's just she is at times abit too much.

• A lot of scene stealers in this drama. Lee Deok Hwa is just a force of nature. He steals the show whenever he appears. The queen is also remarkable. And stunning! Took me a while to realize she was LJK's sister in Flower of Evil. The scheming head court lady is another noteworthy performance. Her motives are actually understandable.

  The actress playing the princess aunt just acts like a whiny little spoiled brat. Maybe that's the goal but there's no nuance or depth in her performance yet.

  I've seen some criticism of LSY on other forums. While I see where they're coming from, I like Deok-Im and her friendship with the other colourful court ladies.

  • Lee Deok Hwa has been gaining a lot praise from the viewers too. I know this article does not mention him but he has been fantastic and the audience loves his scenes with Junho especially. I concur with another poster above that the aunt is the mixed bag and I have a feeling the acting is deliberate but let's see as time goes. Maybe there will be a 180 shift of character at some point.

    • Maybe not only 180 but 360 degrees, his character will die and King Jeongjo (Lee San) will ascend to the throne.

  • wwhy was she criticized?

• Given the overall affect of this drama is so good, I guess critique is understandable.

  The problem is the princess aunt character comes of so childish, and spoilt...but all the more reason to dislike her :)

  The queen exudes royalty and Jung Hee Jin is doing a stellar job. Regal, intelligent, fair (so far at least).

  Personally, I feel most of the cast is doing a stellar job, however CP, the King and the Queen standout.

  I know this article isn't about LSY, but I had to give my 2c.

  I am a huge Lee Se Young fan, however she sort of fades into the background. I can't help but wonder if that isn't deliberate. She is a court lady, she isn't meant to shine. I actually think a lot of actresses would have declined the role. In some of the BTS you can see she spends a lot of time kneeling, bending etc. She can't do comedy as well as she does melancholy; however there is no denying her chemistry with Junho :)

  Hope the drama continues to do well!

• Ok,to be fair Seyoung is a veteran actress and no more praise is needed to be said for her every drama.
  Lots of fans including me are not familiar with Junho and other stars of RSC , so with good characterization which make us notice their brilliant acting , words of praise will come out.

  Lee seyoung greatest acting was already shown in Clowned Crown .
  Here in RSC , her chracter doesn't have many scenes to show strong emotions.

  I think the acting from both leads are strong.
  The microexpressions on the day of Coming of Age Ceremony are the best.
  The happy to sad expression from Deok Im and regretful expression from Crown Prince were shown by our leads.

  • Sorry but JHJ is even more veteran than LSY so your comparison doesn't make sense. In fact LSY doesn't have any breakout role yet but JHJ is completely stealing the show from her in terms of both acting and charisma. Junho isn't being praised because he just got noticed but because he is just that charismatic in every single scene even with the bare minimum expression he is impressive with just his on screen persona. LSY has been getting a lot of criticism as is fair because she does fade into the background and if I didn't know better would have assumed she is an extra but I also blame this on the writer because she does not have the strength to write female leads as was seen also in Ruler. Some writer are better at writing everyone except the lead characters.

    • I agree that LSY is not a scene Stealer here, but disagree that she hasn't had any breakout roles. For once she won an award for Laurel Tree Tailor, and did amazing in Kairos. She does fade on the background when compared to Junho because he really is killing it. However,I think she is doing quite well and their chemistry is really good.

    • Lee Se Young is awsome. I feel her vulnerability, and she at times act out Junho whish understable. I've never feel is not in her character. sometimes fangirl is so bias towards man. it unreal. Junho deserve his praise because it's really hard an idol act in sageuk. but to think he ac oit LSY?

    • @missjb- so true. The bias towards leading men is unreal and people are so quick to blame actresses for poorly written roles.

    • @missjb

      You have a point. And because the target audience include those same fan girls who want to swoon over oppa, the male leads are written to shine so bright while the female leads are written dull. I also feel some people are going overboard with this Jun Ho praise to the extent of undermining other actors just to elevate him. He's doing great but Red Sleeve isn't even his first sageuk ever so it's not like he was some sageuk greenhorn. And it also helps that all the other elements of production like plot, directing, set design, cinematography, etc. have also been solid thus far which makes the drama a complete package. He deserves applause but not at the expense of denigrating others.

    • The problem with actress fans is, if the male lead is given praise they feel entitled that by default the female lead should be given praise as well. These fans will throw this misplaced so called ‘feminist view.

      Why in One The Woman, when all the praises were towards Lee Honey, did any of Lee Sang Yoon fans complain? N, because Lee Honey deserved all the praises.

      The same case here in The Red Sleeve. Why people can’t just accept that Lee Jun-ho’s performance in this drama is superior amongst all actors in this drama. His performance is just natural and genuine. Closed second is Lee Deok-wa. The chemistry between Lee Jun-ho and Lee Deok-hwa is amazing and they both explode when they are together in the same scene.

      Lee Se-young is one of my fave actress and have liked her since Hit-The-Top. She’s my top choice amongst actress her age but whilst she is adorable in this drama and she’s good but her performance is not something that will leave a mark. It’s what it is. Why? She’s really good at some scenes but there are scenes that she missed. Consistency is what she’s lacking in this drama.

      The comparison between Lee Se-young and Jang Hae-jin performance is just unnecessary. JHJ screen time is far too less to be compared to the female lead.

    • Having said that, Lee Jun-ho and Lee Se-young scenes are my favourites. They are so good together.

    • I think Lee Se Young is more veteran than Jang Hee Jin. She was young Choi Geum Young in Dae Jang Geum. And its not her first drama.

    • @MistyEyes well said. I have liked Lee Se Young since A korean Odyssey where she actually stole the show from the bland female lead . But here although she is doing a good job, isn't consistent like say lee deokwha or junho. I like those parts when she stands up for herself, talks abt her own self worth. But sometimes like u said, she just fades into the background.
      As for Junho, this is my first time watching him. And I am simply awed by his performance ever since the first time he appeared on screen. That man really has the it factor. And no we aren't oppa fans who are exaggerating things by uplifting junho at the expense of the fl.
      You have to give credit where it is due. This has nothing to do with feminism.
      Despite all this ,their chemistry remains superb.

• I'm glad this drama is getting praise but also fair criticism in regards to Seo Hyo Rim. She is really one-dimensional which is surprising since historically her role was different. Yes, she was politicially powerful and somewhat an antagonist but she was also supposed to protect Yi San at first when he was a child. Which is kind fading away.

  As for Lee Se Young, she doesn't get criticism. I think she is a bit in a difficult place with her role since she is supposed to act playful/youthful at first. I think she is rocking the serious scenes with dignity and I hope the upcoming episodes will depict her talent more.

  • Lee Se Young is pretty great as an actress....Kairos, she did amazing work. But here, both the time she fell in the water with Junho came across excessively contrived. She shines in the quiet moments better and the others are also enjoying better characterization of their roles so that helps to prop their acting up in comparison as well. But all around, she is doing decent job here.