Comments

Lost You Forever Chapter 10: Who Knows Your Sorrow — 108 Comments

  1. Jing is such a sweetheart. I love Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao’s interactions. They just click (mostly from all those years spent together), and are so honest and bare with each other. For once there is a rational perspective behind political scheming. Thank you, Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao. Chang Pu’s suicide may seem like a romantic gesture, but it really affected Zhuan Xu’s psyche.

    Xiao Yao is such a Daddy’s little girl. Being Gao Xing’s princess will let her get away with any and everything. It is the best protection that the Grand Emperor, who can’t leave Five Gods Mountain, can give.

    I miss that there is no one left who can call Shao Hao by his name. To the world he is the Grand Emperor and not Shao Hao. The path of an Emperor is a lonely one. I don’t really get his marriage with Consort Jing An. I get that she and A’Heng look identical, but Shao Hao isn’t the type to be moved by such superficial similarities.

    • I don’t feel bad for Shao Hao AT ALL that there is no one left to call him his name. Like – ZERO FEELING BAD. He would do it all over again if he could. It’s impossible to read the early parts of Once Promised without literally bursting into gasping sobs because it was all once so so happy. The Gao Xing Prince Shao Hao. The Sheng Nong Princess Yun Shang and Sheng Nong Prince Yu Wang. The Xuan Yuan royal siblings – Eldest Prince Qing Yang, Fourth Prince Chang Yi, Ninth Prince Yi Peng, Princess Ah Heng. Toss in Chang Pu and Zhu Yu for more fun times. Everyone was so fucking happy and growing up together and then we get the a total rocks fall down ending.

      I mean, the final 6th chapters is pretty much total death and destruction of a magnitude never seen before in novels. How could Zhuan Xu be alright? Chang Yi’s death was totally Shao Hao’s fault as well. Shao Hao may have only tangentially impacted what happened to Qing Yang, but I totally put Chang Yi’s death on his head. Ah Heng divorcing him? Pffft, I would have shivved him. Poor Zhuan Xu, watching Chang Pu commit suicide (and trying to take Yi Peng with her first) is the stuff of eternal nightmares. Then Ah Heng taking down her 9th brother and then the Yellow Emperor trying to kill his only daughter and the kids Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao were there watching all of this? The Xuan Yuan family is so messed up Xiao Yao’s wandering 300 years might’ve been the lesser of two evils.

      Shao Hao is so broken inside where it counts I’m not surprised he found a deaf-mute Ah Heng doppleganger for his consort. The Shao Hao in the beginning of the novel, perfect handsome and best friends with Qing Yang, that Shao Hao would have never. But the end after the final battle, it’s conceivable that it’s the only peace and solace he can find when everyone is gone around him. Shao Hao taking good care of Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao? That’s like the least he can do. If he didn’t, I think as a character he would be dead to me forever. Zhuan Xu is Chang Yi’s son and really he’s like a mini-Qing Yang! How could Shao Hao not love him. Shao Hao probably looks at him and feels less shitty about how he tossed his best friends under a bus to become the Grand Emperor.

      • …You are definitely scaring me off rereading/finishing Once Promised. I like my angst, but this is drowning in the river of tears. (Also a reason why I can’t watch Game of Thrones.)

        Tong Hua is certainly good at giving us happy beginnings and ending with rivers of blood and tears. She is definitely pouring on the tragedy by showing us that they had good times together and weren’t enemies the whole time. Although that does remind me of Shao Nian Yang Jia Jun, happy happy brotherly fun, then they all (pretty much) die in the last 5 episodes…

        If Xiao Yao didn’t go wandering for 300 years, I don’t know how she would have turned out. Not as bitter as she is now, but definitely not as naive as A’Nian. Would Shao Hao have married Consort Jing An if Xiao Yao is there as A’Heng’s memory? I can’t really say since I still can’t figure out why he married her.

        Even if he would do it all over again, doesn’t mean he should be alone. He has made his choices, but it doesn’t mean I can’t feel bad for him. He does feel guilty for the rest of life, which may not be much, but it is something. I suppose I should be happy that A’Heng did try to kill him after all the problems he caused.

        Would you mind explaining why after the Yellow Emperor tries to kill her she still fights Qi Yo for Xuan Yuan? Especially since she publicly declares her love for him.

      • I meant that she didn’t try to kill him…

        Battles for the throne always have such a high mortality rate.

      • skyblu – I read the few chapters in which Chang Yi dies in battle, Chang Pu commits suicide and tries to take Yi Peng down with her but instead ends up killing his mother, A’Heng then kills Yi Peng because she knows that Yi Peng will try to kill Zhuan Xu whose mother (Chang Pu) killed his (Yi Peng’s) mother. I know that xia0yuer translated the part where A’Heng kills Yi Peng; I believe ShuShengBar has a link to it on the Once Promised page. The gist of it is that A’Heng successfully kills Yi Peng, but right before he dies, they both flash back to when they were younger and played together; there was even a time when they were both attacked by a demon and tried to save each other and were both physically scarred as a result. You could say that in that final moment before death, A’Heng and Yi Peng finally forgive each other. Yi Peng even says to A’Heng, “The final demon was too strong for both of us.” You can interpret for yourself what “the final demon” is referring to.

        When the Yellow Emperor finds out that A’Heng killed Yi Peng, he is enraged and tries to kill A’Heng. He reveals that when they were young, he ordered for A’Heng and Yi Peng to take lessons from the same shifu so that they would grow up together and learn to care for each other. He also reveals that he ordered the imperial doctors to keep their physical scars from the aforementioned demon so that in the future, they would always have a physical reminder that there had been a time when they cared for each other and tried to protect one another, and that would hopefully prevent them from one day trying to kill each other (which, well, happened).

        In that moment, I truly became disgusted with the Yellow Emperor, and it’s also why I have such a hard time reconciling him with the much-mellower Yellow Emperor in Lost You Forever. Granted, from a logical POV, it was smart of him to force A’Heng and Yi Peng to grow up together, to hopefully prevent this kind of tragedy from happening, but the root of the problem still stemmed from him: A’Heng and Yi Peng’s mothers hate each other, because they both love the Yellow Emperor.

        Anyway, the Yellow Emperor isn’t successful in killing A’Heng because Lei Zu (her mother) comes out to defend her, and A’Heng coldly reminds him that he never revealed the truth behind her 2nd older brother’s death. I didn’t read all of Once Promised, only the last few chapters, but I think the implication is that Yi Peng’s mother had a hand in A’Heng’s 2nd older brother’s death, and that is why the Yellow Emperor covered it up.

        As for why A’Heng agreed to go out to fight Chi You, I didn’t read all of those last few chapters, but I think that the Yellow Emperor was injured in battle, which made A’Heng realize that no matter what, the Yellow Emperor is still her father. Additionally, from the spoilers in SSB, I think the Yellow Emperor convinced her uncle to convince her to lead the army. What can I say, the Yellow Emperor is very conniving. It’s what makes him a good emperor, but a terrible father/husband.

      • Just wanted to add that at first, I didn’t understand why the Yellow Emperor was so enraged by A’Heng killing Yi Peng that he tried to kill his own daughter as a result. After all, this is hardly the first time that A’Heng’s mother and Yi Peng’s mother and their respective children have killed each other.

        Let me emphasize beforehand that I did not read all of Once Promised, just a select few chapters toward the end (and mostly became I wanted to see the interactions between Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao as kids XD), so my understanding of Once Promised is woefully incomplete, aside from what I’ve gleaned from the spoilers in SSB.

        Okay, with that disclaimer out of the way, I think the reason the Yellow Emperor was so enraged was because Yi Peng was the last survivor of his mother’s children, and with him dead, all reminder of Yi Peng’s mother was wiped out. (The Yellow Emperor’s remaining sons – i.e., the imperial uncles that Zhuan Xu refers to – are the issue of his 2 other consorts.)

        I think that between Lei Zu (A’Heng’s mother) and Yi Peng’s mother (sorry, I don’t remember her name, and I don’t care to look it up ATM, that’s how disgusted I am with her), the Yellow Emperor actually loved Yi Peng’s mother more; I believe they were sweethearts before the Yellow Emperor went off to fulfill his ambition. The Yellow Emperor married Lei Zu primarily for the power that she could bring him, and that is why Lei Zu is his Empress and not Yi Peng’s mother.

        The thing is, Lei Zu really loved him, and I think the Yellow Emperor also came to love her. However, Yi Peng’s mother refused to let go of him, and eventually all her scheming and conniving drove him away. Ironically, right after he cut off all ties with her, she sacrificed herself to save Yi Peng from Chang Pu, and as a result, the Yellow Emperor felt immense guilt towards her. Then A’Heng goes and kills Yi Peng, and now you see why he was so enraged.

        Of course, if I got any of this wrong, those who have read Once Promised, please correct me. 🙂

  2. Oh the solemn promise of fifteen years. I know from what you’ve ms. Koala that the story will span a long period of time and shouldn’t worry too much about Xiao Liu being able to keep that promise or not but when Zhuan Xu said he will have to use her and she willingly accepts I panicked.

    Right now I really don’t feel a love bug between Zhuan Xu and Xiao Liu, just two should that are happy to see and be together again, so his words worries me about what he will do because like she said he had ambitions and ruthlessness when needed. And all the talk about marriage seems like a foreshadowing to Xiao Liu being pushed into one.

    I think the pacing in this chapter was toned down but we’ve hit major plot discoveries that kept pushing the story forward so I have a bad premonition about the grand emperor. In almost every story that exists the dad always dies! Now I pray and wish that isn’t true because he is a dad I root for (except for when he allows Xiao Liu to abuse her powers because I think he did the same for Ah Nian and that’s why she’s the big brat engraved into our brains)

    Once again thanks for the chapter and I really admire the speed you release them. Have a wonderful night.

  3. Thanks Koala! I can’t wait to discover the future. I think this chapter has been mostly the calm before the storm. It’s going to get tricky soon!

      • The birthmark is where the Face Forming Flower was inserted into her body by the Grand Emperor and the Empress (Xiao Yao’s mom). She did it so that she could transform Xiao Yao’s face at birth and arrange it so she would resemble the Grand Emperor. Otherwise she would be in danger if she looked like her real dad General Qi Yo. The Grand Emperor knows Xiao Yao is not her daughter since (1) he never consummated the marriage to her mom since they had a marriage in name only and (2) Xiao Yao’s mom told him she was carrying Qi Yo’s child. The Grand Emperor is just sad since it’s a reminder of the woman he loved but who never loved him back and instead had a mad torrid love affair with another guy and had his child.

  4. Haha I love the scene b/w Xiao Yao and the Grand Emperor in the Qi Qing Garden! She’s so adorable with her Daddy! I adore the way she get so exited over her doodles! ah yah Xiao Yao! I hope that won’t change! Why do I get a bad feeling that politics is going to come in and ruin the good mood?? It’s such a good mood!
    Also, I can’t believe that Shi Qi is GONEE now! What am I going to do?? I feel so lost without his heart melting present! 15 years might not be a lot for gods, but still a lot of things can happen then! Haha does anyone feel like they are going to be angry at Xiao Yao if she breaks Shi Qi heart like me??
    BTW, can anyone explains to me the part where Zhuan Xi told Xiao Yao that her mom kills Qi Yo?? what happened??

  5. Thank you thank you so much for the translation!!!! So addicted to this novel!!! On a side note, is once promised worth reading?? That is taking into fact that I have to relay on audiobook cause I can’t read Chinese…. Is it really sad?????

  6. My heart am hoping Xiao Yao will end up with Jing but at the same times I have the feeling that Xiao Yao isn’t the Emperor’s daughter, instead she has a demon father and that she will end up with Xiang Liu becuase they have something in common.

    I want to ask you for spoiler but at the same time i want it come as a surprise….but like a child i can’t wait….:)

    Koala….thank you so much for translating this piece, it’s been brightening my days.

    • It’s not a spoiler, I wrote in my post for chapter 1 that Xiao Yao’s real father is General Qi Yo and not the Grand Emperor. This is not meant to be a spoiler – anything that happened in Once Promised is open for discussion here.

      • Thanks for clarifying it. I haven’t read Once Promised so the discussion above really helps me understand the background story of what happens before.

  7. I don’t know why but I just can’t warm up to Shi Qi. He’s too perfect. Xiao Yao clearly has some feelings for him which she’s suppressing at the moment but she doesn’t seem to be in love as well. I’m still not on any ship but am doubtful I’ll be on Shi Qi’s. I have absolutely no idea as to how things will progress which is one of the reasons I’m loving this story.

    • Yes, Shi Qi seemed too perfect. I think because he treats Xiao Yao so well and is willing to do anything she asks of him that Xiao Yao may not realise her true feelings for him. It’s like we sometimes take our loved ones for granted and just accept the things they do for us without thought of thanking them. Only when the loved ones leave us or stop their kind deeds do we realise what we have missed.

      • This perfection he seems to have might actually turn out to hurt Xiao Yao in the future. She trusts him, though she’s trying not to and if he fails her in some way, the inflicted sorrow will be much worse. I think she’s aware of his goodness and she’s not taking him for granted at the moment.

  8. I was really eager for Xiao Yao’s emergence here but I guess we have to wait a bit longer. The Grand Emperor seems like such a wonderful Daddy. I guess I need to know what happened in Once Promised to understand why he and Xiao Yao’s mother divorced. The Grand Emperor knows that XY isn’t his real daughter though, right? Since he and A Heng were the ones who put the face changing flower in XY?

  9. Reading how they described Xiao Yao’s biological father, Chi You (Qi Yo), as a monster makes me so sad. I’ve been reading Onced Promised, and even though I’m only up to chapter 7, I feel like Chi You is my baby! Ok sorry.

    Xiao Yao thinking that her real father is a monster really does break my heart though.

    Thank you for your translations Koala!

  10. At this stage, I would think that in terms of a maiden love, then Xiao Yao has it for Shi Qi. She blushed, she could feel his heartfelt love for her. She agreed to wait for him for 15 years.

    With Zhuan Yu, it is the love between siblings who grew up together and went through sad, hard times together and understand each other so well.

    With Xiang Liu, it is like fatal attraction. Fascinating, exciting and dangerous.

  11. why couldn’t i see right after you posted? I always saw the post after 8 hours had passed 🙁 what is the problem?????…

  12. Thank you Koala for another update! (= I am enjoying this novel so much! The Xiao Liu and daddy moments are so cute. It’s a little sad that he never got his happily ever after. He’s like the perfect dad, so loving and patient even though he knows she’s not his. He didn’t say he will remove the object, but that he will help her find her face. If she looks like Qi Yo, then the whole world will know that she’s not his real daughter, no? Does he want her to know that truth? I wonder if Zhuan Xu knows and he was trying to make Xiao Liu not think about useless things to protect her. I am a little sad that the Grand Emperor doesn’t have a son. Or does he and he’s just not mentioned? Even though gods are immortal, but they could still die and as Emperor, not having a Crown Prince or a next in line is a big issue. Even if he treats Zhuan Xu as a son, but he’s still a Xuan Yuan Prince and the court will never have it for him to be the next Emperor. I was a little shocked, but not entirely surprised that Zhuan Xu had such ambition. He really does tell Xiao Yao everything! I’m sure he’s never talked about such things with Ah Nian. I wonder how Ah Nian would react to this sister of hers. Ahh.. I’m starting to miss Xiang Liu. I’m assuming he’ll show up at the Little Zhu Yen’s Autumn Tournament. I just hope he’s not Ah Bi or Lie Yang, but based on the character descriptions from the time she was young, I doubt it.

    I guess Zhuan Xu will probably use Xiao Yao to return back to the Xuan Yuan when she returns to visit her grandfather the Yellow Emperor? And who is Royal Mother? Is that the Yellow Emperor’s mother or Grand Emperor’s mother, or neither?

    • After reading Koala’s comment about how the Grand Emperor got to where he’s at, then I guess he had it coming not getting his happily ever after. Regardless, I’m at least happy that he is sincerely trying to be a fatherly figure for both Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao and I hope they never find out the truth. Their lives already suck and to throw in another, “My daddy or Master is the reason for the death of my parents” is a hurdle I rather them not need to encounter.

      If the Yellow Emperor tried to kill Xiao Yao’s mom, why didn’t he try to kill Xiao Yao as well? Don’t they usually kill the descendents to prevent the whole revenge thing from taking place? Or does he somehow care for his grandchild? The Yellow Emperor just seems very ruthless to me. I guess he did also send out an edict looking for Xiao Yao when she went missing.

  13. Such a mellow chapter…I wish to go back to the first arc, where everything was rather mundane and calm. Furthermore, now that everyone is seeing Xiao Liu/Xiao Yao as ‘her’ and not him, I have having trouble seeing her in the appearance of a man.

    Shi Qi, you must not leave! I worry that her promise to Shi Qi will conflict with the one to Xiang Liu. Either of you, come back! I wonder what will occur during the span of 15 years. Will Shi Qi be able cancel his engagement with Yi Yang?

    The story line or the characters from the Once Promised was referenced extensively in the chapter. If Xiao Yao is love child of Qi Yo and A Heng, why did she kill him (or so the fox claims)? Moreover, royals of the ancient time (albeit being set in world of lore and gods) could divorce! That was quite a surprise. I am also enjoying the strong roles of the female character, notably, Xiao Yao and the prostitute whose name I cannot recall at the momment. Xiao Yao may be considered a special case, but her ‘genderless’ relationship with the other male leads was the hook that enticed me. Well, we ultimately figure out that Shi Qi and Xiang Liu knew. I would have liked to see their response or the development of their relationships had they not known. (Why did you have to blush?!) Perhaps, this was for the best as the male characters in a gender bender always ends undergoing a phase of confusion, “Am I gay?” phase as I call it. I mean, Shi Qi, what if Xiao Liu was just insecure or shy? Anyways, I am anticipating the revelation of her true appearance. Would she be ugly as she predicts (for the worse)? I highly doubt that, but Shi Qi’s remark captured the essence of love as relationship NOT based on superficial concerns such as looks.

    Thank you very much! I am euphoric to find the Chapter 10 just as I conclude Chapter 9. Keep your hard work.

  14. I can’t help thinking zhuan yu is a little bit like meng jue. Ambitious. I hope he won’t hurt xiao Yao in the process

  15. Well, indeed the time zone here is different from the time zone in my country…. Looking at the comment, i really wanna read once promise very much. Koala said that after reading Once promise, you will find that Yun Zhong Ge is only a Trip To Disneyland! How come? In Onesecondspring bloc, she writes only the summary but i really would like to know all of the story? ____ Koala plz, do the translation of Once Promise…

  16. All comments make me desire to know the story of A Heng and Chi You. Even though, she killed him or not, their love seems to be eternal and the strongest one. It’s like the proverb: in this lifetime, if we aren’t destinied to live together, we will die together and live together in another world.
    Ms Koala, plz translate Once Promise…

    • I think we shouldn’t pester Koala to do this do that. She is already using her precious time to churn out these articles and translation fast enough to satisfy the curiosity of you readers. Do you not want her to sleep in order to do another translation? She’s not paid to do so.

      • i didn’t mean to pester her. Well, i beg for her to translate but it doesn’t matter if she can’t. I merely wanna know the previous story and feel passion for it like you have read DaMoYao and insist on reading YunZhongGe. I know that Koala has tried hard to do this work and i didn’t paid for anything; i can only read her translation and post comment to show my support.

  17. Thanks a lot for translating this novel. Really really appreciate your hard work 🙂

    This novel is just so awesome. I don’t think I can choose one guy to root for. Basically I change who I like according to what happen in the latest chapter XD. Can’t wait for the next chapter!

    Words can’t describe how much I love this world created by Tong Hua. Never once did I feel bored reading all the translations.
    I love how Xiao Liu is cautious, mellow, weird and reckless. And I love how she feels real. Her scene with the Grand Emperor’s wife is the saddest scene so far. I almost cried when she just totally lost control and thought that is her mother T.T. I love how Jing just dotes on her and try his best to appreciate every moment with her. I love how Xuan just pines for her so much it hurts to read about it. I love how Xiang Liu seems cruel on the surface but beneath that, he truly cares about her. All of them are just amazing.

    I cannot imagine this being made into a drama. I don’t think anyone can bring justice to the characters D: Especially Xiao Liu’s character. I guess this is how it feels to have a book you really like to be adapted. I can only hope the adaptation will end up decent.

    Thank you once again for introducing and translating this novel. What an amazing treasure you had shared with all of us. And for that I’m truly grateful to be introduced to LYF 🙂

  18. Thanks Ms Koala for the update! I have finished the book but it’s still fun rereading it in English here and correlating with the original text. This is a more mellow chapter but I enjoy reading about their relatively innocent time right now.

    Can’t wait for the next chapter as one of the side characters I enjoy (who sadly does not appear often) will be there!

  19. WOWW, it’s so FAST!
    i thought this chapter will be out tomorrow so i was shocked when i refresh this blog and voila, there’s 35 comment already.
    maybe if knew about XY’s dad story before, i might have a different feels about him, just like you feel Koala. But here i don’t read Once Promised yet so i think he is a great dad.
    I should read it after this novel end.
    maybe i’m missing Xiang Liu too much so suddenly I have some cute imagination about that dining scene. Jing absolutely will assist her, Xuan will just looking at her and Xiang Liu probably will smack her and tell her to stop. LOL

  20. Hello Ms. Koala!

    Just wanted to delurk to THANK YOU for all of your translations! I have fallen hook line and sinker for this book and I can’t tell you how excited I get every time I see a new chapter come out! You are the best!

  21. Thanks for d recap Ms Koala!

    Btw, can someone please take pity on me and enlighten me as to how d emperor recognized Xiao Liu a couple of chapters back???

    *dying to know & cant understand d Chinese version*

  22. After finishing the book I couldn’t stop thinking about it for days, but now I’m actively trying not to think about it because then I’d inevitable start sobbing (even watching Bu Bu Jing Xin’s MVs make me cry). It’s so good to read your translation though and remember all the happy olden days.

  23. The scene between the Grand Emperor and Xiao Liu was so touching. Even if he isn’t her birth father, he still her father in every way that counts. Xiao Liu still has a big heart, as she tries to alleviate her father’s guilt.

    My favorite scenes are between Shi Qi and Xiao Liu. They just get each other. They enjoy each others company alot. I’m sad he had to leave and I get why the writer did that, but I want more Shi Qi and Xiao Liu scenes! I hope he comes back before the 15 years are over since I will miss him.

    Zhuan Xu has been through so much, I don’t understand why a mother would commit suicide and leave her child just like that. And she has the gall to ask for forgiveness? WTF! And she lets her son watch her. Its admirable he wants to get back his kingdom but I fear he will have to pay a severe price for it. More than he already has!
    I don’t think Xiao Liu will be able to help him that much because one way or another her paternity will come out. Will the Yellow Emperor want to kill her like he killed his daughter because she is the spawn of his enemy? I hope not.
    Before this chapter I thought she would be destined to marry Zhuan Xu but now I think its Xiang Liu (and he is my least fave).

    I think my Shi Qi is out of the picture since they are like so many obstacles preventing them from getting together. I don’t think he will have an easy time breaking off his engagement. He will face so much pressure in addition to the stress he feels in with his torturer brother. I hope he survives and Xiao Liu waits for him.

  24. i will surely miss jing gege.Xiao Liu please wait for jing , iwill be very heartbroken if u let another man enter your heart…

  25. Xiao Liu’s interaction with Shi Qi just made me giddy. The way he treated Xiao Liu with sincerity, devotion, and respect, melt my heart.

    I doubt there would be any romance between XL and ZX since the latter is full of ambition. Our XL prefer a simple life which ZX would not be able to provide, i reckon.

    Where as Xiang Liu, i do not get this guy. Does he like XL? Or does he see XL as his kindred spirit? I did not feel anything, not even the kiss scene at the bottom of the sea.

    • However, I must say that I am grateful that Xiang Liu took the lovers bug from XZ. At this stage, he is the best person to retain the bug. He is stronger physically and mentally, compare with either Jing or XZ.

  26. Looking forward on the next chapter. Somehow, I really missed the “fiery” interactions between Xiao Liu and Xiang Liu. All the sparks flying. 0.0

  27. OK, after ten chapters I have managed to keep my heart’s alliance neutral. I think it has to do in part with XL disappearance in the last two chapters. (on a side note, XL is probably too degrading to call our third hero, makes him sound unfit and large. Lol!)

    17 (Shi Qi- yes I’m lazy) is too docile for my liking. I can appreciate a man with a quiet demeanor and all out unconditional love but it seems too simple for our heroin. She needs more zest and and spice in her man! Seeing as how sassy she is leads me to think that she could either

    A) fall for 17 bc he supports her antics no matter how outrageous by sacrificing even his own life. But I would think that love might be obligatory
    B) fall for him because she needs stability and a constant after all the upheaval she has been through and all the other crap that will probably happen

    Gege is gege as in her brother! No after how you slice it (at this point) she sees him as a link to her happier past. Her love for him is pure and void of complicated feelings. If she didn’t go through hardships ad left him for a few centuries I don’t think she would even miss him. Perhaps look at him fondly and protect him at all cost but not at a cost to her heart.

    Gege seems to love her as a precious person because he knows he could lose her at any point and he even substituted her with another sister, whom might I point out is loved and coddled despite her bratty behavior. It didn’t matter how our heroin behaves or becomes, he loves her because he would be broken and aimless and without purpose. His love for her is his purpose to keep on living… At this juncture.

    Last but not least, XL, I secretly feel like he would be the best for fit for our gal because he is so intriguing and broken. Our heroin probably feels akin to him because they share not only lineage but deep scars. (somehow Gege’s hurts don’t measure up but nevertheless he is still tragic.)

    BUT!!! I cannot full support this pairing in my mind because he is so abusive and manipulative! I wouldn’t want that kind of relationship for anybody. Fictions or otherwise! And yes I understand their worlds, power and dynamic is different than our real world being princess God’s, demons and whatnot. But Still!!!!

    Anyway, that’s my stance for now. Who knows what happens to my heart or her allegiance next.
    Ps,Koala, I comment in thanks to you. Know that I have not put such effort in commenting since I was a student. And that was many moon’s ago.

    • There was one part where there was sizzling chemistry between Zhuan Xu and Xiao Yao. When Zhuan Xu was pierced by Shi Qi’s fiancé’s arrow and wouldn’t stop bleeding, he sent for Xiao Yao. When Xiao Yao saw him, she touched his blood and tasted it to ascertain what poison he had. Zhuan Xu felt affected by her actions and had to compose himself quietly.

      I am afraid my ship is Zhuan Xu and I fear it would be a tragic one. I always like the soulmate and brotherly jibes, not to mention his tragic past and I like ambitious guys.

  28. Thankyou miss koala, (alot of kisses from me are already flying in air to reach you. Hah) I have read all, all all your translation and I love each one of it,and then seeing another translation in progress was like a surprise gift.Boom!! Ah.. Thanks again.
    The comment referring to the the previous book, once promise cleared and mad alot of things much more interesting, not that it lacked any before . just enhanced it, I’d say.
    As of now, my heart lies with shi Qi as best, not because his perfect but I really liked what he said to her in the prison . he thought he was perfect but he realized he was not in such an ugly way, he was broken and dying, had given up but she found him and gave him a reason to live . when everyone find care about him without his name, she gave him a name and took care of him. And how can he try his best to give the perfect love to that person?Now he’s got everything back but to him nothing is worth without her. And there’s so much more to talk about their relationship, so much.. It’s everything that makes me root for them. So please don’t go wrong in 15 yrs time.

  29. Thank you so much for the translations! I love reading them and it’s making me discover a new book. Suppose this would be the motivation for furthering my chinese studies so I could read the orignials. If only I had classes and wasn’t in a “Pick it up as you go along” situation.

  30. Would anyone please keep on referring to once promise in the comment section, that’s the only way I’ll know what happen back then,. As I’m far from learning any Chinese.
    It would be if the ones who have read the book once promise explain few interesting plot lines of it.. 🙂

  31. Thank you again Ms.Koala! This is something I look forward to reading everyday! !! I must say the illustration above is breathtaking. Totally befitting of Xiao Yao. Haha. Keep up the awesome job!!! Sending you loads of virtual hugs!!!

  32. Thanks ms. K for another marvelous chapter and uber thanks for excerpts of Once Promise *xoxo*

    I’ve tons of guesses in my mind!!!

    I feel XL will do a bigger than Big Bang comeback in the tournament. It’l be fun for XY wt complete attendance of her men harem *swoony* ! Lets thrown in sure dumb struck Ah Nian.

    GE is very much a father for XY. He even helped XY’s mom to plant a magical thing to change her face.

    My lovely Jing, he took the fox’s tail wt him…i guess, to try to bring back XY’s spiritual powers or to at least give her powers.

    If XY’s mom killed her demon real dad…i don’t think she will eventually fall for XL. She will not want to repeat history again. I just wish ZX will not get blinded by his lust for power and revenge ( as LBY did in YZG ) and lose XY by his side. Will the grand emperor try to rectify his evil past by making or letting XY happy….wt Jing ?

    Awesome possibilities *whew* TYSM ms. K *mwah*

    • Oh my!!! Someone should dispose of XL before he’l use XY’s promise to him. I felt so sure he’ll ask XY to love or be wt him….or else, XY’s love will become pain something. How devious of XL…maybe, there’s a huge reason why she killed XY’s demon dad.

      • Nee hee…we need an edit comment option and a Like button.

        I meant, maybe there’s huge reason why XY’s mom killed her demon dad…

  33. Thanks for another chapter!!
    I’m really into this book and I wouldn’t have the chance to read it if it weren’t for you. So thank you!

    With each chapter we get to know more and more about Xiao Liu, and I already love her. I think she’s very strong and very real. I totally understand her growing walls around her heart to protect herself, and always expect something will separate her from her loved ones. I think Tong Hua really knows her characters. Each one is different, all of them have their own personalities and feelings…

    I haven’t made up my mind about who will end up with Xiao Liu. I don’t think that it’s important right now, since we’re still getting to know all the characters better. I think she likes Jing because he makes her feel safe, like he’ll always be beside her, always support her… I can’t see anything but brotherly love in her interactions with Zhuan Xu. And Xiang Liu is still a mistery to me… can’t wait to see what’s the importance of the bug.

    I’m so sorry Xiao Liu lost all her powers. I think she’d be really badass (even more than she already is) if she could get her powers back. Also, the Flower implanted in her explained to me why she lost all her powers but didn’t lose the ability to change faces. It’s because it’s not her power, she wasn’t born with it, it’s something that was implanted in her and can be taken out.

    I really like that the Grand Emperor is nice to her, but at the same time I’m afraid he isn’t all that good, or that something will happen and he will disappoint Xiao Liu. Maybe because I don’t know what happened in Once Promised, so I don’t know the characters from that book very well. But I’ll keep reading the comments and discussions here, which are great, and maybe I’ll catch some background explanation 🙂

  34. This was such a great chapter in my opinion. I think it highlights the loyalty and deep devotion Xiao Liu and Zhuan Xu has for each other. I think their love spawns out of a place of desperate protection and loneliness. There is this feeling that they both are all each other has in the world. Moreover, this stems from their mutual understanding of loss. This is what really connects them– they both understand what it means to lose their loved ones in a blink of an eye and have your whole world turned upside down.

    I think it is great how Xiao Liu have this mutual understanding with all three leading men. Xiao Liu and Zhuan Xu’s understanding comes from a shared history of loss. Nobody will understand their pain except each other. Zhuan Xu does not let anybody see him cry except for her. From this perspective, no one can understand Xiao Liu’s deep loneliness more than Zhuan Xu.

    For Xiang Liu, I think out of all the three male leads, he is her soulmate. They get each other in a way that needs no words or outright admission. Zhuan Xu and Xiao Liu can talk about all the ways they have suffer and share their worries. Xiang Liu and Xiao Liu gets each other without saying so, with denying it at every point. I always have a feeling that if Xiao Liu met her three male leads in modern times without all the complicated circumstances, only she and Xiang Liu would hit it off right away. They would be the weirdos at the secluded lunch table and be perfectly content with each other company. Xiang Liu appeals to the part of Xiao Liu that is unbriddled, ardent, and adventurous.

    And for Shi Qi, I think their relationship is the one that takes most effort to understand. To be honest, I think Shi Qi tries very hard to understands Xiao Liu because he loves her, which to me is more endearing. Xiao Liu may not always understand Shi Qi’s or intentions which is the reason why she always test him. She falls for him because even when Shi Qi doesn’t understand her reasoning or actions, he always follows them without hesitation. Who would not love that?

    All three men are great leading men in terms of love stories. You have the ambitious leader in Zhuan Xu, confident and strides with purpose. You have the forever honorable rebel in Xiang Liu, the gallant bad boy. And finally, you have the devoted lover in Shi Qi, intelligent and gentle. I can see why the shipping wars would get crazy for this one. How do one chose over what seems to be three perfect men only wishing for the happiness of the female leads?

    I can’t wait to read on. I’ve been skipping ahead through the Vietnamese translations even though I only understand about 50% of what is going on. I should have paid better attention during Sunday school. I am so happy that you are doing these translations and am looking forward to it everyday. Would it be too much to say that this is literally the highlight of my day?

    • In a high school drama – Jing is the smart valedictorian from the wealthiest family in school who gets beaten up at home by his dad, Zhuan Xu is the captain of the football team and class president who gets along with everyone, and Xiang Liu would be the loner who smokes out by the bleachers and ignores everyone but gets a perfect 2400 on his SAT scores and no one knows he volunteers at the homeless shelter every weekend.

      • Did you just recast the better version of what “Heirs” should have been?

        (btw thank you for translating this story. I don’t know any chinese at all but have been sucked into the beautiful prose)

      • Lol-ed when I read your comment koala… you should write your own novel with those leads, sounds great already!

      • and what would Xiao Yao be? She’s such a unique heroine that I’m having a hard time picturing any actress playing her.

    • Could I ask where you’re reading the Viet translations? Thanks!
      Also Ms Koala, your descriptions of the 3 guys as high school students below cracks me up..

  35. I’m torn after reading this one. Loved her daddy interactions and conversations. SQ left her???….still have not boarded a ship but really do love the Zhuan and Shi characters for her. Can she not have a reverse harem?

  36. I have been a silent reader for such a long time, I remember the last time I commented on your blog was when you translated DMY. Anyway, I want to say a big big thank you for translating this novel and introducing this to us. After reading 5 chapters of yours, I couldn’t wait anymore and tried out the Chinese version, although I only understand like 70/80%, but it is alright, I get the context, so I am kind of ahead of the story, somewhere at the beginning of book 2. But I still follow your translastions, it gives me full details of what happened, so for that, thank you again.
    Anywy, somewhere at the end of book 1, I was so afraid my ship would go down, so I went around to look for spoilers. And then I found out the end, I read the last chapter and the epilogue and I feel bad. Even though my ship sailed (happily) away, but I am still heartbroen for that other ship which went down. Horrible, sometimes I hate TH for making such kind of happy endings. I was feeling so bad back then for Meng Jiu in DMY.
    For now, I pretty like Jing for his devotion, and of course the bad boy, Xiang Liu. I don’t feel any vibes between Xiao Yao and Zhuan Xu yet. Although I admit, he would be her first priority, but it’s not that kind of love, just brother and sister relationship. I do wonder what happened in Once promised, but I am really afraid to read it. I remember YZG, I only made it till Ling gege’s death, then I stopped reading. Actually, I was desparately trying to find a short summary of Once Promised in English, but I found none. But I am really curious about Chi You’s and A’Heng’s relationship, perhaps you can summarise it sometime when you have time, that would be great. Anyway, thanks again for this wonderful translation.

    • I was also curious about Once Promised too, but I really found onesecondspring and shusheng bar helpful 🙂 if you read the comments on Shusheng bar you get a pretty good grasp on what happened. The first blog I mentioned she’s currently doing chapter summaries. I hope this helps you 🙂

      • Thanks for the sites. I’m going to take a look later. Hope I do get a good overview of what happened to the older generation back then.

  37. I waited so impatiently and constantly refreshing but here we are now with a new chapter!! Thank you for all your hard work Ms. Koala. I greatly appreciate it! 🙂

    The story is a little bit slow paced right now, but it is understandable since XY is still making up for lost time with her families; however, I still enjoy seeing her be daddy’s little girl and Zhuan Xu fawning over her as if nothing ever happened.

    As of right now, shipping wise, I am still team XY & XL, despite the fact that he has been missing in two chapters but I can wait 🙂 I do agree with most on here that I don’t see XY having any feelings for ZX like the way he does. I know right now her heart is definitely with SQ but I really dislike his sort of passive behavior. He just lets her do whatever and follows her around. He has his moments of taking charge, but it all feels bland to me their chemistry. But I guess ultimately he is what XY needs because he’s always there and she fears being alone.

    That is just my take and I am enjoying reading everyones responses. I am excited for the next chapter!! Again, thank you so kindly Koala!! <3

  38. Thank you so much for another great chapter. It’s so good that I gobble it up so fast that it’s over before I realize it. Of all Xiao Yao’s men I still don’t see her with ZX and see her as loving him only as a brother. I’m guessing her dad will try to marry XY off to him & she’ll go along for awhile because she feels like she should for her dad & ZX. I’m sure ZX loves XY so he’ll go all out to win her heart but I find his character still lacking and I can’t root for him.

    My current ship is XY with SQ but it is starting to bug me that he lets XY get away with anything & doesn’t deny her every whim even if it’s bratty. He doesn’t challenge XY AT ALL and that’s no way for a relationship to be .. He might as well be a slave…albeit a looove slave but still.

    Since XL wasn’t I’m

    • I didn’t finish my comment… Since XL wasn’t in the last chapter I am still not on his ship but I see more potential in him to being THE ONE because they both share with each other their pain & sorrows early on already & they both challenge each other. I didn’t like XL’s meanness before but we’ll see if he changes. Also I like that he comes to save XY and is willing to defy the Emperor for her but respects her decision when she says she’s okay. Hope to see more of him soon!

      Can’t wait for another chapter! Jia Yiou Koala!

      • Xiang riding in on the waves to get her was total bad boy hotness….I still haven’t warmed up to his character even though the writer describes him as smexy flying on a winged creature….

  39. Oh btw koala I LOVE the pictures/drawings in your posts! Are they actually from the book or from other sources that you just liked & felt like it matched the chapter? Either way they are beautiful!

    • All the pictures are from other sources. The three volumes of Lost You Forever do not have any illustrations with it EXCEPT for the illustrated poster that comes with volume 2. It’s the picture I put with my translation of chapter 1. It’s also the picture in the “Currently recapping” section where I listed Lost You Forever. It’s an illustration of Xiang Liu and Xiao Yao walking on the ocean and is the only official illustration from the publishers for the novel.

      • To be honest, I really wish I had unread this comment because I feel if I link your comment of this one to another from a previous chapter I think my heart is going to sink into the depths of the ocean. *sighs*

  40. Hmm, Where to start….

    First of all a big THANK YOU to Ms Koala her who is putting so much effort into translating this book. I cannot read Chinese nor understand it so this is a huge favour you are doing for us non chinese speaking people.

    I miss Xiang Liu so much. I’m shipping him as he literally lights up the pages when he makes an appearance. Xiao Yao and Xiang Liu have a sttaction and understanding which is somethign only they both know and appreciate. I love that he has been described as the bad boy on the bleachers and I always love characters like them.

    However on the other hand, Shi Qi breaks my heart. I’m not on his ship but the way he dotes on Xiao Yao and follows her around is just so sweet. I think Xiao Yao like him now as he seems really loyal to her and that’s what Xiao Yao craves, someone who would not leave her.

    Zhaun Xu so far gives me the bestfriend/ brother vibes. They have different chemistry together but it’s only due to the past they have shared.

    I think this is how the story line will go. Shi Qi leaves and the Xiang Liu somehow reappears in Xiao Yau’s life. They fall in love but Grand Emporer doesn’t like it as Xiang Liu is a demon. Then Shi Qi comes in the scene and more drama follows and then the Emporer tries to marry off Xiao Yao and Zhaun Xu and Zhuan also want Xiao Yu as it ful fills his ambitions. More drama follows and then some one dies and it’s a happy ending. What do say, huh???

    That’s my prediction but lets’s see how the story really goes. I do hope Xiao Yao gets his powers back and I get to see Xiang Liu again soon. I’m really missing him. Here’s hoping that Lost You Forever will not have lots of bloodshed but only bucket loads of tears.

    Koala keep up the hard work. We love you.

  41. Thank you for the the speedy translation. The plot is getting thicker. I can sense that Jing is getting jealous of Gege but Xiao Yan does not even have a clue. Or does she really have no clue?

  42. It may be repetitive but thank you!!!!!! and also I miss Xiang Liu so much!!! I am curious about we get a background story on him. Do demons have parents? So far it says that demons are evolved from animals right?

  43. I’m curious to know how Ah Nian will feel when she finds out that Xiao Yao is a girl? And as her step-sister too??? She’s been raised very loved and spoiled by everyone. I’m afraid she won’t like the idea of sharing her father now 🙁

    • Actually I can’t wait for Ah Nian to find out! She’s such a super brat that this should knock her down a peg & I will enjoy reading about it! I want her to witness how much the Grand Emperor & ZX dotes on XY. Especially since she’s been SO mean to our beloved heroine!

  44. Hello LittleTamV again!
    I have to say this chapter sooth me after what happen to the previous crazy heart wrenching reuniting chapter 9. ~Reunited and it feels so good!~ That’s how it feels like now, but… Shi Qi is now out of the box/chapters and so is Xiang Liu for now. (Noo~) I hope this chapter and the few other chapters will develop or make up more for the reason why Zhuan Xu and Xiao Liu will have a “romantic” storyline. After reading this, it helps me understand and develop a skeptical feel for Zhuan Xu. At first, he was the one out of the three lead main guys that I feel the least attach too because he had this detach feel when first met. The business smile, the unmove face, the one you can’t predict Xuan. However, after reuniting with Xiao Liu, I felt that he is just like a little introvert child that needs some love and support and an irritating brother that one who have siblings can relate too. Xiao Liu to him, seems to be the bright sun in his world. I know my curiosity wasn’t able to hold reading a chapter per day (again I still thank you Koala for translating this for us out of your busy life) so I did some crazy. research. on what I can find on the book even though I don’t know Chinese much. I now know a few gist of what is going to happen later and maybe? the ending but I won’t spoil anyone here. But I really have a few question I really wish if Koala or anyone who read any further can answer. It might spoiler some readers, so I won’t give out too much.

    So here’s my questions:
    1. Do you know when they will reveal the birth secret truth to Xiao Yao and maybe to the rest of the world? It’s been rumor here and there, but when will she realize the real truth? After we see her real face? The Grand Emperor does know that she is not her child right? (I want to read Once Promised to know how Shao Hao reacted but I’m too weak-hearted for the storyline and its characters ending. I will be depress for days if I do read it.)

    3. The four leads don’t die right? I will be depress for months if they do. I don’t even care if either the 3 of them don’t have Xiao Liu. I just want them all to be happy. But two ship will eventually sink and one will sail to the end of the earth.

    4. Especially to Mrs.Koala, I know you did this to Da Mo Yao and Yun Zhong Ge before, so I am curious who do you think will suit the characters here if it was made into a drama ancient series show?

    Well that’s some of my curious questions I have so far. It’s barely the 10 chapter and it’s gettin’ so good! But I have to say I have a ship now! I hope it sails ‘til the end! Hint: He who can make Xiao Liu heart skip and he who can make her get mad as times because of his actions. *Laughs*

  45. Hi! I hae been a lurker seen…I think two weeks ago and I wanted to say thank you for sharing this story with us(especially with us non chinese readers). Because of you I discovered another great writer and her wonderful works. I would like accompany you in your journey of translating this wonderful story. Please don’t let go!(Although I’m glad you discontinued translating YZG because I was so heartbroken with Liu Fu Ling’s passing D:)

  46. Thanks Captain K! You rock!!! I guess I am currently in the no ship boat. Still gotta learn more about each characters. Thanks again!

  47. Thank you, Koala!! I’m grateful for your selfless effort in doing this. In between your chapter releases, I try to read a little of the original, only ending chapter 4 now. What I do most is checking out the thoughts and explanations over in the last translated chapter, I enjoy all the sharing! Am looking forward to seeing Xiang Liu (in another form?) soon in the little tournament. So cool if all the three males and Xiao Liu reunite in the tournament. Wonder what events they will compete in… Mmmm definitely archery.. Still thinking what Xiao Liu might participate in.. poison challenge??

  48. Not sure how anyone could’ve missed Xiang Liu’s feelings for Xiao Yao since the clues are literally everywhere. Perhaps, being way into a particular ship doesn’t allow one to be more objective when it comes other MLs? When Xiang Liu took Xiao Yao to see the moon in chp 4, when they were strolling on the ocean. Xiao Yao suddenly grabbed Xiang Liu’s arm & he stopped for no reason. In chp 7, when she was grabbing his waist very tightly, both of their bodies were “stiff” for a moment. After taking in the lover’s bug, he took Xiao Yao to explore the underwater for a very long time. When she fell asleep on the condor, he touched his heart & smiled briefly. In chp 8, he pretty much traveled tens of thousands of miles, risking death to take Xiao Yao back to Qing Shui Town. Also, every time he took blood from Xiao Yao, the author would describe the marks as “resembling a kiss mark”. I don’t think Tong Hua would choose these types of words if it was just a simple teeth mark & he didn’t have feelings for her. Xiang Liu may not say out loud that he likes Xiao Yao but his actions speaks louder than words!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

error: Content is protected !!