Comments

Material Queen Episode 7 Recap — 7 Comments

  1. I enjoyed most of this episode, as I do MQ in general, but I hated the preachiness of the market-saving scene. 🙁 It was overbearing to have Patricia Field essentially spew a speech about treasuring cultural and historical landmarks and saving the Due South Market without having ever stepped foot near it, I felt. It’s all well and fine that the residents, their neighbours and Yen Kai Ming’s team see the market with their biases and personal motivations, but for her to step in and deliver a speech that basically felt like “I know better, and you’re going to regret this if you don’t do what I say” was OTT and well, wrong.

    And that scene with Allen’s mother, to have shot it with everyone looking around felt unreal. As much as I appreciate the sentiment, I thought it was out of character for Allen’s mother to back down in public. If no one had been looking on, I’d have accepted it, but considering she’d lose face to a massive degree with the crowd looking on, her response took me out of the scene.

    However, the personal scenes were really well done. Chu Man’s interactions with Jia Hao, the market people and Yen Kai Ming were all fantastic. Pity it didn’t carry over to the crowd scenes.

    • I agree that Allen’s mother didn’t seem like one who’d appreciate being put on the spot, though I can see her backing down considering she’d lose even greater face* by refusing her son’s obvious (and public) affectionate offering.

      * though this may be cultural (as USian), since I don’t know if it’s an accurate assumption that a Taiwanese mother of upper-middle-class standing would have qualms about yanking her son into line despite his obvious good intentions. I mean, I’d like to think all parents show/have love for their children, but different cultures express this in different ways.

      That said, I do agree about Patricia Fields… not quite lecturing, but it came kind of close… about the value of the market as a cultural force. If this had been a USian production, I’d be quitting at this point, because it’s a scene with too many shades of privilege. But being a Taiwanese/local production, it’s more complex than that. Fields is being used as a cultural icon — an almost pan-cultural icon, given her status in so many countries — and speaking in defense of another cultural icon. But she’s also a non-Chinese person, telling Chinese people about the value in their own culture, so there are shades of a need for external validation (ie, “someone from the West says it’s okay, so hey, it’s okay after all!”) — yet those words put in her mouth were put there by a Taiwanese script-writer. I think maybe the goal was less malicious/complex, in that one artistic visionary (in fashion) was recognizing a different but equal form of cultural power, and lending a bit of her own power to others, in a different field, but with the same motivation as Fields herself: to create joy in the world. Plus a bit of rank-pulling (which runs alongside the issues of privilege), in that these low-class market-sellers aren’t expected to have such a powerful (and external) figure in their corner.

      What made the Brother Sharp part — finding his girl after so long — work for me was that the real narrative reason behind it isn’t even mentioned. I would’ve expected some confrontation (or some introspection, as Taiwanese rom-coms seem to be big on the introspection voiceovers) about this re-finding forcing Chu Man to revisit Jia Hao’s question of whether she’d accept the existence of love if Brother Sharp did ever find his girl. But there was none of that; it just went on by. If this were any other drama, I’d call it sloppy writing, but this drama, I’m learning to trust. It’ll come up again, but subtly, and perhaps not even directly. The lesson is there, though, and the point’s been made. The drama won’t dwell, but it won’t forget it, either.

      Lastly: I swear, Chu Man deserves her own country just for having the chutzpah to stand up to YKM. The man seriously scares me, and I’m not usually scare-able. He makes panthers look cuddly and easy-going; I think you should go back to the shark metaphor. Someone cue up the Jaws theme.

  2. I’ve just watched MQ with sub yesterday, and reading your recap adds the fun….
    ooh YKM is really something… a panther… yup…
    and I can see ChuMan also trembles in front of him
    but anyhow, if she accepts him, will she find her happiness?

  3. finally caught up with all the eps over the weekend. phew. Yen Kai Ming – SCARES me too. seriously, how does one even meet up with him privately? If there’s the equivalent of the emperor – he fits the bill. & if in a period drama, Vaness would be the general and Chu Man the favourite concubine 😛

    Loving this show. It’s not making me want to fast forward the time (which I’m truly thankful for as a drama viewer). I like how the drama sort of sits on you and you taste it unfolding. Really loving it more.

    Some say, Andy An would be good for the show… but I think Lynn is perfect for it. I like how shades of her and her gradual warming up to alien ideas like true, genuine, unassuming affection is making this a perfect set up for the clash later. I’m a sucker for characters that perceive how the situation is in the drama and acts it out knowingly – like Jia Hao – he knows where he is based on Chu Man’s equation of life. And he lets her know it, without any reciprocation expected from her… wow. I really like it.

    I do wish Xi Li Ge did leave with saying bye face to face. It felt weird suddenly all the technology descending on the market… I mean we’re 21st century yes but … it’s traditional market. so.. nostalgia… surely a letter?? hahah sorry.

    Romeo / Da Bing – he brings on laughs for me everytime he appears – in FTLY, every time her gets me. His sudden popping up on my screen – was so great. Like a long time friend. hahaha.

    It’d be so funny if there ever was a episode where different characters from different dramas dropped by to shop. hahaha.

    • in a period drama, Vaness would be the general and Chu Man the favourite concubine

      I was thinking Vanness would be more like the foot-soldier. Whatever’s about as low as you can get, even if he has potential for one day being more. Right now he’s… pretty much a peon. A cute one with great abs, but a peon all the same. XD

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

error: Content is protected !!