Comments

The Blade and Petal Episode 1 Recap — 32 Comments

  1. Beautiful cinematography. I don’t love sageuks generally, but I gave a try on this one and dammit, it is awesome beyond words.

    • Agreed…but I’ll definitely check out this show. It looks and sounds awesome.
      About IHYV, the premise sounds wonky but the product is amazingly good; not at all melodramatic or fluffy.

      • Yes, i hear your voice’s premise was so meh that i didn’t even know it was premiering until after GF’s recap. Well, anything GF likes i’ll probably like considering we have very similar tastes. Checked out first ep, but wasn’t really hooked until the 3rd. Now, i’ve come onboard the rollercoaster ride that is Voice.
        I’m going to be watching I hear your voice for the feels and Blade and Petal for the badass.
        Yay for good shows airing, i remember when we were all in a slump a few weeks ago.

  2. Kim Ok Bin is gorgeous in every angle. The cinematography is bloody insane yet the visual storytelling really works well.

  3. I’m glad that this drama got your attention and it helps it gets subbed fast. I feel like watching this drama in full HD, every detail is so clear crystal and sharp. The colors used are also unusual for sageuk, I have impression watching a movie. I also like that they emphasis more on actions rather than dialogues. In some scene it works very well, like when Yeon Choong meets his father, both father and son scarily resemble each other. I haven’t gotten hold of Moo Young character yet, I find Kim Ok Bin lacking of expressions, either she’s trying not to overact but turns out kind of flat to me. Hopefully it’ll change when more things happen in future eps.
    About the ost, I absolutely love the one during action scenes, so thrilling; while on other hand the one during their 1st encounter was little unfitting? idk it’s too upbeat to me, but after the 1st time it’s become quiet addictive as well. just wish the scene was done differently cause it was way too cheesy and eye-roll worthy to me. well i guess they wanted to affirm that these two are indeed Romeo & Juliet of Goguryeo..

  4. Glad you’ll be recapping this drama. It’s good to get another opinion. I think the music bgm that they used is fit with the scene, remind me of Damo.
    But Damo used techno music and here they used rock.

  5. So many times, while watching this episode, I was not sure if it was my computer tottering or the scenes plodding… 🙂

  6. I am desperatly starving for a good Wed-Thu drama, but just couldn’t force myself to like this one. It just didn’t feel as a whole piece to me…those beautiful bit’s and bites here and there couldn’t buy me as a viewer.
    I’m still giving it another try today…

  7. i tried this one…the cinematography is good like watching a movie but the acting and some action scene is awkward…i’m not satisfied with the leads acting (except 2 super senior)..the story is kind of slow too
    i also read some negative review about the actings and the slow in some korean sites

  8. It’s weird for me. I mean the cinematography is beautiful but the music when they first met eye to eye is so ridiculous and awkward. Not to mention the girl flying in the air, stop and posed like spiderman reversed scene made me laughed so hard. And then out of a sudden, coming out from nowhere..wind and petal flooding the screen. It’s supposed to be romantic but I felt the scene is forced, fake and extremely awkward. I decided to leave the show after that.

    • Yes, the petals. Hahaha. I was looking for a eunuch on a rooftop spreading petals at princess’s request; it was so unnatural. So many things are unnatural about this drama but it does flow and grabs my attention. Right now I am watching for general Yeon. He is such a mystery to me. Some profound sadness and resolve, with loyalty to his country.

  9. There is something intriguing about this show. I didn’t like some of the camera work in the beginning of the episode but I am hoping that it will improve. Some of the transition scenes were also a bit awkward. The first episode was a little strange but since I like strange things I will continue with the show. It sounded like some psychedelic music when the two leads first truly met each other.

  10. So i came back after finishing ep 1 of Blade and Petal.
    I think i wanted to like this show more than i did.
    I didn’t buy so much into the romance considering alot of it was gazing at each other for several minutes and like some have mentioned — it felt forced and unnatural. I’m sure the following episodes will develop the romance, i just wish the director didn’t decide to go all cheese on us in the first episode.
    Speaking of director(i really thought this first episode was all directing and barely any dialogue after the first 10 minutes), there were moments that brought me out of the mood. The awkward spiderman save (which was replayed a few times), the long awkward gazes, the misplaced songs that remind me of old western movies and cowboys. I think they need to tone it down a notch. There was alot of attention to little details (the rustling of clothes, thumping of feet, tapping of fingers, random petals, etc,etc,) that i thought was overdone.
    I think i wanted this first episode to have more oomph, but one can only tell after giving this show a few more episodes.

  11. The first episode did grab my attention. It was slow on some parts but I was intrigued by other parts especially the tension between king and general yeon. Plus, the cinematography is quite unique and artistic. But after seen episode 2, I have totally lost my interest. It is so slow and boring and dose not emote any emotion at all 🙁

  12. Both the director and KBS are gutsy for presenting such a stylized drama on prime time. I’ve seen the director’s previous works, White Christmas and the Equator Man, which were visually pushing the kdrama cinematographic boundaries. I specifically remember some of the more visually experimental scenes, framing, shots in Equator Man, some of which I found a little too hamfisted and inconsistent. Now, I definitely get the sense that the director wants to introduce a whole new visual vocabulary to kdramas. I applaud the attempt, even if that visual vocabulary in Ep 1 felt very much like an experimental work in progress. I haven’t seen enough C-drama or Jdorama to know if those works already employ such visuality, but French cinema did come to mind. Especially La Jetee, because this episode challenged kdrama genre’s sense of time and action. Though this approach didn’t hook me necessarily, it is intriguing and I’m curious to see how the visual language develops.

  13. I hear your voice is one of these shows you just dont judge it by its cover its fresh like you wouldnt guess you dont feel youve seen it before

  14. I like your opening description of the drama. I just watched the first episode and came up with a few notable points. I’ve read comments by people who thought it sucked cos of the lack of dialogue and the pace of the episode. On the contrary, I could sense the tension building up because of the silence, and the pace of the drama fully allows us to analyze every scene. The execution of the concept made it intriguing instead of coming across as dull. I do understand why it’s not receiving as much attention as it should be. This drama is not everybody’s cup of tea, especially since most people these days prefer fast-paced action and compelling story lines. I feel that TB&P is the sort of drama that would be appreciated by viewers way after it ends its run (assuming they don’t fall offtrack halfway through), sort of like the response toward The Great Gatsby novel.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

error: Content is protected !!