Comments

Gu Family Book Episode 2 Recap — 63 Comments

  1. OMG thank you for agreeing about Seo Hwa being a complete nut job! I get that her being upset is a given, but really she was stupid enough to bring those goood for nothing soldiers to moonlight garden to kill WR? wow! tsk tsk.
    Ok since there is a possibility of Wol Ryung being alive, then the plot I read about in January might be true for Gu family book. Apparently WR will lose his memories and work with the enemies (without having aged a day >.< yippee!! ), and there will come a day when Kang Chi will have to fight him. That will be interesting, but I really don't want that lol
    thanks for the recap!! hoping it doesn't digress further into the episodes, I can't not watch LSG!! 😀

    • Because you know a Gumiho that does everything to protect her and lie to her about the deaths of her maid and brother is more worse than an old man destroying her family because he lusts for her and ultimately turns her into a prostitute and kills her brother + forces maid to commit suicide is a better option.

  2. I totally agree that Seo Hwa’s actions in the second half of the episode were entirely nonsensical. I have absolutely no sympathy for her character, and in fact, feel sorry for those that sacrificed themselves for her, ie: her brother and the maid. That writing was so terrible.

    And yes, the English song is driving me nuts too. It’s so off-putting somehow.

    Other than that, I pretty much enjoyed the episode. Especially the first half. I’m ok with them having spent all the time with the couple in the episode, just because there was a lot of stuff squeezed in to such a small amount of time. They could have spent two more episodes on the parents and I wouldn’t have minded, and perhaps it would have done the storyline more justice (and maybe Seo Hwa wouldn’t have had to turn bipolar just to advance the plot).

    But of course that would mean cutting into Seung Gi time, and we can’t have that. 🙂 Still going to keep watching and hope it picks up again. Now that they’re through rushing (hopefully) things will get back to better writing.

    • Seo Hwa’s flight to the enemy might have made more sense if her character was more fleshed out – for example, if she was extremely superstitious and afraid of ghosts, monsters, etc. or if we saw that she had a backstory with Mr. Evil being kind to her, or if we saw that what had happened to her had permanently damaged her ability to trust, love, and think rationally, or if we saw that she was already wierded out by her husband’s odd behavior and abilities. I can think of plenty of ways to make her actions at least a little bit more understandable, but instead she just moves at the whim of the plot. Written with a fat crayon, indeed.

      • Exactly! That’s why I almost wish they hadn’t rushed through this segment of the story, if it had been fleshed out better then maybe (maybe) it would have made sense. Perhaps.

  3. oh noes!! :/

    I sped through E2 and couldn’t understand the misunderstanding b/w the parents. While I DO understand SH unraveling upon learning the truth it annoyed me still. Very much so. Poor WR!!

    ugh, I hope for Seung-gi’s sake that the writer doesn’t go cray cray on him AND us. Lastly, in the preview Suzy had dead eyes when KC’s all like, “I’ll protect you”. This is kindaaa not looking good.

    • “Lastly, in the preview Suzy had dead eyes when KC’s all like, “I’ll protect you” – Agree with you, Saima.

      This scene reminded me of K2H when Hang-Ah ran out from her room and hugged Jae-Ha. You can literally see in Jae-Ha’s face that he might feel something, even though no words were spoken. It’s so different here, even with the narative.

  4. I had the same reaction, “WTH?” Not only did she run away from him, but she even went to the people who wants her ass captured? PLUS she helped the person who framed and killed her own father and tried to turn her into a gisaeng into killing/capturing her Gumiho lover? What in the flying fuck was that? Dear writer, she could’ve just ran away from BOTH, you know.

    Then of course she realized it waaaay too late. Can’t we have one drama where people could behave rationally? No matter how scared I would be, why the hell would I go running to the people who want me dead? I’ll just ask the blue thingys to carry me to Hawaii or something.

  5. I knew it ,i knew it, i knew it this happens every time i like the first episode i end up completely disappointed!

    From now on i only watch dramas where i HATE the first episode , from there it can only get better!

    • lol! But I feel the same way.. I JUST finished the 1st episode, and go to check the recap on the 2nd epi cause I’m just wary that way about anything makjangi. Well, I guess I’ll drop this series like a hot potato then. Too bad…I really like LSG, but I never ever watch any drama for the sake of an actor/actress.

  6. The writer rears her ugly head. It is pretty dumb to spend so much effort making viewers fall in love with the characters in the first episode, before destroying them in the second. Cold water poured on the warmth and heart no doubt.

  7. @koalasplayground: if you really want a drama to complete you, go watch Nine. You’ll fall head over heels with it! 🙂

  8. I agree, except I didn’t really like Seo Wha in the first episode, either. I felt sorry for her, really, really sorry, but I wondered if she was really the person Wol Ryung thought she was. He had no basis for loving except her face and the whole damsel in distress thing.

    She was awfully quick to sacrifice her sweet little maid, and that seemed unnecessary- it didn’t gain them any time at all, really. She was unnecessarily scornful and snotty about the Gisaengs- having wrongfully ended there herself unfairly, she might have given at least a small twinge of sympathy to the idea that those ‘lowly’ women might not be there by choice, either.

    • Your second point does not reflect the way of the past. The yangbans would pride themselves to die instead of being humiliated/violated. So those who took the route of surviving/prostituting is looked down upon. She wanted to die but couldn’t for the sake of her brother. So this point is coherent and accurate. Though it can be further argued that the others gisaeng faced the same problem but that is too far fetched. The scorn for gisaengs has always been true for common folks and even more the yangbans.

  9. OMG, i suspected the 1st ep was written by the writer’s assistant and then writer continued the rest :)). How can the story develop so weirdly? It just made no sense how stupid Seo Hwa can be. But I guess it means her love for him isn’t that strong like his so she’s so easy to be swayed, but trusting the words of your father & brother’s killer? That’s just nonsense. I had super high hope after watching ep 1 but super worried after ep 2, please writer, don’t screw it off, for my baby Seung Gi’s sake, please, please, please. Having Suzy in the drama makes me worry enough, don’t pull another Man of Honor please. :(((

    • oh, forgot to add, baby Kang Chi is so adorable, kind of make me forgot about the whole nonsensical writing of ep 2 😀

  10. I think I’ll wait until Lee Seung Gi appears before I spend any more time on this drama. Otherwise, I might get so pissed off by episode 2, I’ll just scrap the whole drama.

  11. Seriously, this writer needs to go back to Writing 101. She could have Wol Ryung be injured while trying to protect Seo Hwa without the betrayal. It’s makes it more poignant to have true love thwarted by Evil Baddy instead of the craziness. If instead of being upset about the baby we could have seen Seo Hwa tell the baby about his wonderful daddy and how they loved each other so much before sending baby away for his safety.

  12. I liked the episode, but yeah the romance died man. I like the monk/gumiho daddy more than SW and WR in the end. I know a lot of people are falling over themselves in love with the couple, but I take this as a lesson in what not to do in romance. This doesn’t diminish my hopes for Kangchi and his journey though. I don’t think YW will do anything as stupid as she did and KC will have reasons to fall in love. So, I’m still very hopeful for the future.

  13. never understood the fascination with lee seung gi…hes not even that handsome (hes got an ugly nose) and hes not even a great actor. is it because ajummas like a young man? like those older woman younger man relationships in dramas? is it because hes a singer and like all idols and singers have a huge loyal fanbase that watch their dramas to make it popular and high in ratings even though its not good?

    so far not rly liking this show.

    • Because 1) Seung gi isn’t plastic and 2) He does things other than acting, namely singing and variety shows. In fact, he’s only done about 4 dramas but he has done more variety gigs and he’s got 5 albums.

      Seung Gi basically has a flawless career for 9 years now. Never got into any scandals, never did drugs, etc. basically he’s normal. He is 6-foot tall, which is a plus for most Koreans. He was president in middle school and high school. He got into university through his grades instead of his celebrity status. He finished his degree in 4 years despite producing albums and appearing in variety and drama, and he’s now in his 2nd Master’s degree. He’s humble, and he even drives the same car as his manager. Where will you find a celebrity that drives the same car as his manager? Not to mention he was discovered and trained under the famed Lee Sun Hee.

    • Lol he’s known as the noona killer ever since his X-man days.
      Ahh, so much fail from just reading the recap. This is why I don’t dl eps anymore lest I end up deleting them

    • Well, the handsome part is really personal preference, but I think that Lee Seung Gi is beloved by people for being the “perfect son,” charming, and all around good guy. I’m definitely younger than Lee Seung Gi, and that doesn’t stop me from enjoying his acting, variety and singing. Don’t throw him into the general idol pool just because he has a fan-base; he’s pretty good at what he does, and therefore has dedicated fans. And no, those fans are not all ahjummas looking for younger guys.

      Please don’t think I’m telling you to like Lee Seung Gi–that’s entirely your choice. I’m just asking that you don’t bash the people who do like him.

    • You didn’t even saw him and is complaining? Pfff talk about hating him.

      He was very good on King2hearts, did you watch it?

      Plus he is loved not because he is a singer, but because the guy is perfect.

      He is polite, funny, always friendly and caring, paparazzi stayed 3 years following him and found NOTHING bad about him, not even one thing.

      His smile is also really warm and beautiful. And his nose, I prefer it than the other plastic noses all kactors have.

    • Eeeer Koala, so it would really make sense for her not being scared of a monster who just killed errr all the men there? Please. Of course she would be scared. Just because the man was gentle and good to her doesn’t make him killing others good or disappear. He is a gumiho. People at that time knew Gumiho pretended to be humans to trick them. She could have felt he was just toying/lying to her and he was dangerous – as he showed to be after killing everyone.

      • It doesn’t make sense in that she willingly went to seek her father’s killer and attempted rapist. Her fear and shock is understandable, to seek out her greatest enemy is pure writer crap. You gotta call a spade a spade.

    • Honestly, I think people who say things like this don’t really know much about him. I’m not saying everyone who does know falls in love with him, but if you knew the type of person he was, his work and image you’d understand the fascination people have. Being handsome or not has nothing to do with it. Seunggi doesn’t live off his face. He’ll still be popular when he’s old and wrinkled because he’s built a solid career and reputation.

    • I never understood the fascination of hanging out on a blog post about someone I don’t Like to post nasty rude comments, I stay away. Why don’t you try doing that as well, unless of course you get off in some way by showing your ignorance in cyberspace. From this point on its all about him, why not try checking out another drama instead. And you understanding the fascination for this guy just in not necessary or needed as for myself and a million others we understand it.

    • never understood the UNfascination with lee seung gi…
      my reasons: you can read the comments above me, starting from @foulou.

      Not sure if English has the word UNsatisfaction, but you know what I mean.^^
      In my humble opinion, you don’t need to question something like this. 🙂

    • I think you should separate the drama from the actor. Even if you don’t like the drama, that should not have any significance to the actor as a person. Moreover, there are many people out here who are not so shallow as to be taken in by looks. True, SG is not among the flower-boy or the chiselled-face category of good looks, but what he has in terms of personality and character far outweigh any good looks. For those of us who are more discerning and put weight on character and talent, LSG is the man.
      Incidentally, I want to say that he is much better looking in person and his acting has improved. He was not a bad actor to being with, but he nailed it in The King 2 Hearts.

      • Too bad for you ! It’s a different story for me coz the only k actor that I ever Iike is LSG.

    • I hav eno problem with his acting or singing. I like it. A lot. But yeah, I also cannot understand the fascination.

    • Mmmmm…… I’m pretty much younger than seung gi

      I do agree that most of drama throw some idols to catch viewers, but I think it’s different with seung gi. In fact, his fans growing after each drama, as his acting capabilities also growing up too. I watch Shing inheritance, My Girlfriend is Gumiho and The King2Hearts, so I think I’m capable enough to answer this, aren’t I?
      As for Seung gi face, everybody has their own preference though 🙂

  14. It hurt to watch this episode and have my hopes dashed. What in the actual fuck was the writer thinking? Now I’m just waiting for the parent section to be over when I was so excited for the parental love story yesterday. To the point where I didn’t want the younger leads to come in yet. Can’t come fast enough now…

  15. Hopefully, Suzy will be a Kagome. She seems more like a Kagome anyway. God, wtf happened in this episode? Everything progressed way too fast and fell apart just as fast. I was so hoping the SH from the preview of episode 2 was some sort of misdirection because she can’t possible be THAT dumb. I was wrong. 🙁 Their preview is exactly what you expect from the upcoming episode, no surprises whatsoever.

    • This will probably be a much bigger hit than TK2H, which is a shame. Though maybe it’ll end up being a masterpiece. I’m still holding out hope.

  16. I am going to ignore the sheer craziness of mommy dearest here in the 2nd half and focus on the actual main characters. She must have been in a pretty “off” state to attempt to kill her own child. Just saying that something must have not been right to even consider something like that as a mother. I am not really a fan of lsg, and I didn’t love K2Hs as much as most people, however, I am still interested in this story 🙂 As someone else said, it’s important to separate the characters from the actor itself. Some stories, people really love and others don’t. In any case, I hope that this one turns out good all the way through 🙂 Fighting!

  17. Is the gumiho father dead? I initially thought that at first but it seems some people have a different interpretation, that the forest is treating his injuries.

  18. Can someone fix my broken heart now, this episode made me cry and I cried a lot.
    I think Seo Hwa got scared, she didn’t expect him suddenly to show his other side and she freaked out.
    In the end though she does realize her mistake and ends up regretting it figuring out that she really did love Wol Ryung and that their child is not a monster. Also I think she was genuinely happy with him living in that very nice cave.
    Now I’m hoping we get to see them kiss and make up in the end riiight, drama pleaaase.

  19. ugh. I was so looking forward to watching this drama but not anymore. I was hoping for just a few good episodes, and I cannot believe its gone stupid already. I just… I can understand Se Hwa running away- but to the man who killed her father in front of her? What does she expect from him?! When has he proved that he would help her?! It’s so utterly ridiculous. And it just makes her feelings for woo ryung seem so shallow, that she does not even consider forgiving him or try to understand him, as you would someone you loved. I feel for WR, though I do wonder why on earth he fell for her. I could have accepted the insta love, if this episode had carried through to show their relationship deepen, and then had it end…in a way that made sense. ugh. so not the moving, powerful love story I was expecting/hoping for.

  20. Love your recap.i’m no suprise or sad about story. Maybe i know it ‘ll happened. But i also falling love story parent. They ‘re good job. I know alot her story. Heartbreak , sad, warm, hard laugh. Story of parent so bad for them, but what happene to their son. If his farther live, he is monster? Wife?love his son so sad too. What that love this story because monster so scare but however human is scare too. Writter good job , she make views falling dad monster than his unlucky son . Story so interest but also some normal too. actor so good, product so good. Hope you recap it until and love your think. I agree.

  21. I guess when watching a drama, more than it being good or bad, the thing that matters is if you enjoy it, like it and are able to connect with it. There were a lot of dramas that people raved about and when I watched it I could see what was good about it, yet I dropped it. And dramas that objectively are bad yet I like it or enjoy it enough to keep watching.

    My point is, I hope the readers do not make decision to stop watching without seeing it themselves. I read your comment for this episode first before watching it, and I think it was not as bad as you make it seem.

    Of course objectively, some scenes and actions are questionable if you think about it but I find this episode romantic and very moving. I watched Man Of Honor, and dropped it just after 1 or 2 episodes. There’s no subtlety at all with that drama, makjang all around.

    This drama and this episode in comparison has a lot of hearts while still having the makjang aspect (even in Ep1). In this episode, I think I started to tear up when SH said thanks to WR and hugged him. I could just feel her relief at that time. And then when WR turned into the beast, fighting the evil guys, OMG, I was sobbing so badly there while finding him very scary at the same time. That’s why I think I can understand SH’s action after that. She loves him, yes. She feels bad for him, yes. But he’s still a scary monster. And if I have a baby monster in my tummy I would want to abort and lose it as well. I think that was such a great realistic conflict. Besides, i think she just seem to go crazy after all these that happen to her that she can’t really think properly. She going to the soldiers is like she’s getting tired of running away from them and just want to surrender herself. i hate it that she went to reveal his place to the soldiers, but the scene following that captured my attention and affected me so much where I was crying so badly again watching WR feeling so betrayed and sad, that by the end of the episode I can say, this is one great episode. Not perfect (I don’t think Ep1 was perfect as well) but a great one nevertheless.

    It’s too bad that you don’t seem to connect with this drama like I do, because I love to read your posts when we are on the same wavelength. I hope the coming episodes will continue to be good. Looking forward to Kang Chi’s story!

    • I so agree with your perspective, everyone is bashing SH actions, instead I think we should be more compassionate towards her, it’s true the episode is not perfect, but I do not agree her actions is unreasonable. We must remember this happened in saguek times and era. Gumiho is feared as much as an devil ?! It is an era that woman has no rights and life’s of the weak am poor has no value in the eyes of the powerful. SH saw the WR rages and the horrible claws. To her he is an unknown creature a monster that is not human. We now lived in a world that feel vampire is romantic? So we are more receptive towards WR but in that era, WR should be very scary monster in the eyes of others. Hence the backbone of the story. To become human. About her giving up the baby. She has hated the baby because she has been thinking of the baby as a monster child, can you imagine carrying a child that is not human? until the last moment she saw that he did not look like a monster , it’s perfectly understandable she could not live with the baby , for reasons, she could not care for it? She could not face the baby. So sad that SH is so misunderstood by most ppl..

  22. I don’t know how you gyus feel, but for me jank Ok Jung may be the One… Suzy’s acting in the preview is scaring me. I looooove Lee Seung Gi though.

  23. I have to wonder if it was really necessary to make Seo Hwa be the worst witch ever?! I mean weren’t their other ways for this to end tragically without her having to betray the man who loved her and try repeatedly to kill their baby?! Seriously! My hate for her now rivals my hate for the main baddie and quite frankly I hope she dies a horrible and torturous death. I wonder if our hero will find out that mommy dearest tried repeatedly to kill him? And I wonder how the OTP will overcome the fact that her dad killed (or seemingly killed) his dad? Argh. I still really like this show and I will watch it, but Seo Hwa just made me so mad that I am having trouble keeping breakfast down.

  24. So is Wol-Ryung still alive? Or was the forest just laying him to rest? If he is, I would be really happy! His character is so cute and caring.

  25. OMG, I watched these first 2 episodes in a college library and Seo Hwa was so effing frustrating the girl behind me secretly watching got angry too. She tapped me on the shoulder to ask what I was watching and then we spent the rest of the episode bitching at Seo Hwa for being such a dumbass.

    We could not even believe it when she not only went back to her attempted rapist and the murderer of her entire fucking family but then she had the gall to lead the soldiers to her husband’s secret hideout?! Talking bout, ‘Why didn’t you tell me about my brother?’ when the damned dude who murdered him is standing right next to her!

    ‘Why didn’t you tell me you were a divine being?’ Dis bitch done lost it. Obviously it was because some small part of him must’ve known you couldn’t be trusted.

    She didn’t deserve anything in that drama. Not her steadfast little brother, not her sacrificially loyal maid, not Wol Ryung, and definitely not his baby. (Still reeling from her about to scythe that baby in the face after she gave birth to him.) The Shame Tree the Madam put her on was too gentle a punishment.

    I’m gonna channel Taylor Swift for one tiny moment and just say Wol Ryung should’a been with me.

  26. This drama is just poorly executed. Even the teaser that shows the main actors, you can predict that there will be tacky scenes in the future.

  27. O.M.G.
    this blows my mind. How can anyone write with this f-up logic, how can anyone let this pass, how can anyone act out this logic? I’ll just erase this episode ever happen in my mind

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

HTML tags allowed in your comment: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>

error: Content is protected !!